Same issue here!
We just installed the Neighborhood theme (love it) HOWEVER it seems that the sidebar selections WILL NOT SAVE on previously created pages (prior to installing Neighborhood).
Here’s a quick Jing video I made for you to take a look:
http://screencast.com/t/5lBovh5WBn0
Though I was going crazy – but this is a PROBLEM. Please advise – happy to provide login info, btw.
Thanks so much in advance.
Barbara
PS – We do have custom fields installed – from WP Types, Views & also the new WooCommerce Views – custom work by the folks at WPML (On The Go Systems), btw.