I fixed it. Pretty annoying, but where we were putting that code states:
Tracking code
Paste your Google Analytics (or other) tracking code here. This will be added into the footer template of your theme. NOTE: Please include the script tag.
The problem with this is that SwiftIdeas must have changed where they place this code. Instead of being in the FOOTER as shown in the text, it was adding the script to the header. Due to this, the script was being executed before jquery was loaded, causing it to blow an error and not work. Adding the fix script to one of the footer widgets placed it below the load for jquery and fixed the issue.
Any thoughts as to why this is loading into the head instead of the footer now?
Any thoughts on why we have to use that script in the first place?